Friday, February 5, 2010

Why so serious? or It's just a f@%$!ng comic book!

Today on Newsarama there was a post by David Pepose about the fact that DC is considering the possibility of doing sequels to Watchmen. Let the fanboy outrage ensue.

I for one don't give a shit whether they do 50 sequels, Watchmen cereal, Rorschach toothpaste and a Saturday morning cartoon using the characters. After all I don't own those characters, DC/Warner Bros owns them and they can do whatever the hell they want.

I enjoyed the original Watchmen as much as the next comic book fan, but it is just comic book, not some kind of sacred text. In the same way Casablanca is just a movie, Huxley's Brave New World is just a book, Elvis was just a musician and Alan Moore is just a writer. Sure all may be good or even great, but they are what they are and nothing more. People tend to attach too much to works and creators/artists that are part of the upper echelon, the best of the best. They attribute an almost sacred aspect to them, holding them in higher regard than they deserve.

I'm not bashing the quality of Moore's work here, I'm simply pointing out that none of this shit is so sacred that it can't be exploited. Common sense will tell you that if it tanks, they won't keep doing it. If it does well then there was demand for it because they put out something that people liked and wanted.

Ok I can already hear the cries of hypocrisy. Wasn't I pissed when D&D 4e came out? Well yeah, but not because it tarnished the name of D&D. I was pissed because of the way I felt WotC treated their fans. I gave 4e a chance and while I admit the system is good, I didn't like playing it. I didn't find it fun.

3e/Pathfinder is the type of system I prefer for D&D. It is that simple, a matter of preference. 4e has not "ruined" D&D or taken away from my ability to enjoy 3e/PfRPG. Do I still hold a grudge against WotC, sure and maybe that colored my judgment of 4e. However, I still own ten 4e books, so I think I gave the system a fair chance. Though in my defense my group didn't care for the system either.

Now what was the purpose of this rambling mess of a post? I guess I just wish that people would get over themselves. Don't take this shit so seriously and don't discount something until you at least give it try. Nothing is sacred and just because you love a certain piece of work doesn't mean that another one can't be just as enjoyable. After all the purpose of comics, movies, games, music, and fiction is entertainment. If they teach us something in the process, build character, or make us think, then we benefit from their existence. Still they are nothing more than what they are, a form of entertainment.

Don't take this stuff so seriously.

6 comments:

Russ said...

I don't think the angst about is really about the titles so much. Hollywood treats the genre like crap and goes out of their way to make sure horrendous crappy scripts are provided to scifi movies. That's got a lot to do with the scifi community being so defensive. It's not about oh noes they're changing the Watchmen. I don't trust those guys to write a movie that doesn't mock the watchmen.

Geek Gazette said...

The sequels are about comic book sequels from what I understand not the movie.

katallos said...

I'm sorry that it took you 10 books to figure out that 4e isn't right for you, that's a huge monetary investment on something that sucks. I was able to determine that it would be no good from the reviews I read shortly after it's release, and a few friends wasted their money on the core books before realizing 4e was no fun.

Geek Gazette said...

It didn't really take me that long to realize that 4e wasn't the system for me. I actually realized that after playing a couple of games with the core books. There are actually 3 primary reasons that I continued to get more 4e books.
1. At the time my group really liked the system and wanted to keep playing it. I'm willing to play anything and since they have no objection with me, as the DM, making changes I figured it wouldn't hurt to get some of the other books. Plus they are FR fans and I never was a fan of the CS. So the time jump in 4e was enticing and the reason I bought the books. It seemed to give a newer FR player a less complicated place to start.
2. Some of them were gifts. The non-gamer friends and family continued to buy me 4e books long after we quit playing. All they knew is that it was D&D and the people at the store said that book "X" was the newest. So their intentions were good. Besides I have books for tons of systems I don't play. I like reading them from time to time.
3. I wanted to make sure that my negative opinion of WotC wasn't the reason for my lack of fondness for the system. I wanted to give the game a fair chance. I may not like it but I do stand by the fact I think the system itself is solid. I just don't enjoy playing it.
There are a few other minor reasons, but those are the main ones.

Custom Thesis Writing said...

this kind of blog always useful for blog readers, it helps people during research. your post is one of the same for blog readers.

Thesis Papers Writing

website development company said...

Excellent site you have got here.. It’s difficult to find high quality writing like yours nowadays. I truly appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!